Pure Coincidence? October 29, 2018

Pure Coincidence?

Are you lucky? I was, a few weeks ago. On 8th October 2018, I posted an article titled “Good Business = Good Investment? Think Again!” And warned that despite new highs, the stock market was facing extremely frothy valuations.

A recent headline in Bloomberg read:
Pure Coincidence?
Looking back, 8th October was almost the inflection point and the S&P 500 has declined about 5.8% since then. Other topics hogging the news include the US Federal Reserve’s interest rate hike agenda, escalating Sino-US tensions, US earnings releases and eyes watching the Middle East.
Pure Coincidence?Chart 1: S&P 500 as of mid-market, 24th October 2018 (Dotted White Line: 8th October 2018, date of previous article posting)

Skill or Luck?

As much as I would like to give myself some credit and say, “I told you so”; this was purely coincidental. Am I able to repeat such a feat again? Probably not. There is little chance anyone of us could have predicted this series of events, especially with precision AND consistency. It wasn’t skill. I was lucky.

So what is the difference between the two?

Luck is when you strike a life-changing lottery.
Skill is when you strike that life-changing lottery, every weekend.

When it comes to your managing your investments, we want to separate luck from skill.

To know how good a manager is, we turn to Richard Grinold’s “Fundamental Law of Active Management”, measured via two variables – Information Coefficient (IC) and Breadth (N):

Variable Measure
Information Coefficient (IC) (2 * % Correct) – 1
Breadth (N) Number of Independent Decisions

Information Coefficient (IC) measures the skill level of the manager and ranges from positive 1 (perfectly correct) to negative 1 (totally wrong). An Information Coefficient (IC) of 0 suggests that decisions made are no better than random guesses.

Say there were five overturned cups with three of them hiding a coin underneath and I have three tries to guess which cups are hiding the coin.

If I correctly get… My IC is… My skill is…
All 3 coins (2 * 100%) – 1 = 1 Perfect!
2 out of 3 coins (2 * 66%) – 1 = 0.33 Quite Ok
1 out of 3 coins (2 * 33%) – 1 = -0.34 Try harder
None of the three coins (2 * 0%) – 1 = -1 Lousy

Breadth (N): measures the number of independent decisions made in the portfolio.

We then multiply both of them to get our Information Ratio (IR), measuring skill level over time.
Pure Coincidence?
If I get it right once, it doesn’t mean much. But if I am to correctly guess where all 3 coins are (high IC) consistently 100 times (high N), then I must be truly talented (high IR). Right?

Shiller: Good or lucky?

The fundamental issue is still, well, about the fundamentals. Valuations are high today, and are amongst the 80th percentile since 1995; a period that includes the dot com bubble. On top of the current environment, there are new concerns that corporate profit growth may have peaked.
Pure Coincidence?
Valuation ratios are mean reverting. That means over time, they converge back to their long run averages. If Earnings (the denominator) were to stay as they are, the only way for valuations to revert to its mean is for Price (the numerator) to fall at a greater magnitude. Given this context, further correction sounds almost like a certainty.

To test our ratio out, we set some parameters:

  1. Investments are profit making when valuations are low
  2. Investments are loss making when valuations are high

We purchase when valuations are at their highs (top 20%) or lows (bottom 20%) and hold them for a specified period. If the parameters we set out are right, more times than they are wrong, we will get a high Information Coefficient (IC).

Here are the results, applied on the S&P 500 Index as a proxy for the overall stock market:
Pure Coincidence?

1 Year Holding Period 2 Years Holding Period 3 Years Holding Period
Valuation Overall Valuation Overall Valuation Overall
Low High Low High Low High
% Correct 95% 52% 73% 95% 67% 80% 100% 76% 88%
IC 0.9 0.05 0.46 0.9 0.33 0.61 1 0.52 0.76

Information Coefficient is mostly on the higher side. Shiller PE Ratio does have predictive powers.

Investing when valuations are low almost guarantees that it will be profit making across all three holding periods tested. I believe this is because stock markets are asymmetrical, with an upward bias. There is a floor to how low prices can go until funds, institutions and other investors enter to swoop them up, supporting the prices.

Investing when valuations are high gave somewhat of a mixed result. One-year returns of high valuations gave an Information Coefficient of 0.05, not much better than a coin flip. This is because of the dot com bubble still forming at that time, providing attractive returns to investors willing to bear the risk, pushing the Shiller PE Ratio close to 38 at its peak.

In periods of high and extreme valuations, a small catalyst may set off a knee jerk reaction. Funds, institutions and individuals act to protect their personal interests, trimming their holdings or cutting their losses. This becomes a case of fastest fingers first, with rapid selling and drying liquidity pushing prices down quickly.

When the holding period is extended to 2 years or longer, then we see clearly – the odds of turning a profit during extreme high valuations are not in your favour.

What then, is the fair valuation for your odds to be decent? Here are some statistics:

24 years
(Jan 95 – 23 Oct 18)
Post-Dot Com Bubble
(Oct 02 – 23 Oct 18)
Mean Shiller PE 22.19 19.62
Median Shiller PE 21.16 20.49
Average Top 20% 31.98 24.33
Average Bottom 20% 14.87 14.3

Shiller PE ratio today: 27.02

What is going to be the catalyst? When and how much is the correction, if any? Or am I just spouting gibberish and coming FAANG (Facebook, Apple, Amazon, Netflix and Google) earnings releases are going to push the index to a new high and make me eat my own words?

This is going to be anyone’s guess!

(*Please note that information contained in this article is given for educational purposes only. Past performances are not indicative of future returns. All information and opinions provided in this piece do not constitute as investment advice.)

About the author

Tan Chek Ann
Senior Dealer

I sleep in the day and head the dealing desk at night.

In my nightly work, I attempt to do analysis, revolving around portfolio construction, long/short strategies, responsible leveraging and factors research.

Join me on my journey as I share my thoughts on various topics – though mostly still financial stuff.

Reach me at tanca@phillip.com.sg

Contact us to Open an Account

Need Assistance? Share your Details and we’ll get back to you

IMPORTANT INFORMATION

This material is provided by Phillip Capital Management (S) Ltd (“PCM”) for general information only and does not constitute a recommendation, an offer to sell, or a solicitation of any offer to invest in any of the exchange-traded fund (“ETF”) or the unit trust (“Products”) mentioned herein. It does not have any regard to your specific investment objectives, financial situation and any of your particular needs. You should read the Prospectus and the accompanying Product Highlights Sheet (“PHS”) for key features, key risks and other important information of the Products and obtain advice from a financial adviser (“FA“) pursuant to a separate engagement before making a commitment to invest in the Products. In the event that you choose not to obtain advice from a FA, you should assess whether the Products are suitable for you before proceeding to invest. A copy of the Prospectus and PHS are available from PCM, any of its Participating Dealers (“PDs“) for the ETF, or any of its authorised distributors for the unit trust managed by PCM.  

An ETF is not like a typical unit trust as the units of the ETF (the “Units“) are to be listed and traded like any share on the Singapore Exchange Securities Trading Limited (“SGX-ST”). Listing on the SGX-ST does not guarantee a liquid market for the Units which may be traded at prices above or below its NAV or may be suspended or delisted. Investors may buy or sell the Units on SGX-ST when it is listed. Investors cannot create or redeem Units directly with PCM and have no rights to request PCM to redeem or purchase their Units. Creation and redemption of Units are through PDs if investors are clients of the PDs, who have no obligation to agree to create or redeem Units on behalf of any investor and may impose terms and conditions in connection with such creation or redemption orders. Please refer to the Prospectus of the ETF for more details.  

Investments are subject to investment risks including the possible loss of the principal amount invested. The purchase of a unit in a fund is not the same as placing your money on deposit with a bank or deposit-taking company. There is no guarantee as to the amount of capital invested or return received. The value of the units and the income accruing to the units may fall or rise. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of the future or likely performance of the Products. There can be no assurance that investment objectives will be achieved.  

Where applicable, fund(s) may invest in financial derivatives and/or participate in securities lending and repurchase transactions for the purpose of hedging and/or efficient portfolio management, subject to the relevant regulatory requirements. PCM reserves the discretion to determine if currency exposure should be hedged actively, passively or not at all, in the best interest of the Products.  

The regular dividend distributions, out of either income and/or capital, are not guaranteed and subject to PCM’s discretion. Past payout yields and payments do not represent future payout yields and payments. Such dividend distributions will reduce the available capital for reinvestment and may result in an immediate decrease in the net asset value (“NAV”) of the Products. Please refer to <www.phillipfunds.com> for more information in relation to the dividend distributions.  

The information provided herein may be obtained or compiled from public and/or third party sources that PCM has no reason to believe are unreliable. Any opinion or view herein is an expression of belief of the individual author or the indicated source (as applicable) only. PCM makes no representation or warranty that such information is accurate, complete, verified or should be relied upon as such. The information does not constitute, and should not be used as a substitute for tax, legal or investment advice.  

The information herein are not for any person in any jurisdiction or country where such distribution or availability for use would contravene any applicable law or regulation or would subject PCM to any registration or licensing requirement in such jurisdiction or country. The Products is not offered to U.S. Persons. PhillipCapital Group of Companies, including PCM, their affiliates and/or their officers, directors and/or employees may own or have positions in the Products. Any member of the PhillipCapital Group of Companies may have acted upon or used the information, analyses and opinions herein before they have been published. 

This advertisement has not been reviewed by the Monetary Authority of Singapore.  

 

Phillip Capital Management (S) Ltd (Co. Reg. No. 199905233W)  
250 North Bridge Road #06-00, Raffles City Tower ,Singapore 179101 
Tel: (65) 6230 8133 Fax: (65) 65383066 www.phillipfunds.com